A listening journal
Rolling Stone 500 · 2013

Number 495 · 1 of 2 Bonnie Raitt albums

Give It Up

Bonnie Raitt · 1972

495
Give It Up by Bonnie Raitt album cover
Cover unavailable

Bonnie Raitt

Give It Up

Released1972
Journal statusOriginal note recoveredPreserved from the 2013 email journal.
Journal checkpointJune 20–24, 2013Interval between retained album-bearing emails · not an exact listen date.

Listening notes

Apparently some blues, could be considered country, a little honky-ish

I definitely am stretching myself in some ways, but in others I'm just finding the artists that have influenced ones that are already popular

reading Taleb's "Black Swan," particularly about how herding works and the economics of success in entertainment, how it is a "winner take all" of a tournament, and the winner need not be any better, just lucky - from randomness. He argues that randomness is the great equalizer, because everyone is equally likely to benefit from it, but I don't believe he is entirely correct in that. But the point I'm getting at is that this list is interesting because we will have albums that may or may not have been popular at the time, and may or may not be popular now, but for some reason they are on the list. it most likely has to do with someone saying an album influenced them, then everyone who is influenced by that person citing that influence as well, thus 2 or more degrees removed, by the luck of a few people an album gets undue credit for influencing an artist/genre/movement, when there are multiple albums of the same quality or perhaps even moreso, and of which may have been equally or more influential, which now are on this list. Regardless, I don't know the story of Bonnie Raitt. By the third song I wonder if she is a more legit Carly Simon

Definitely has to be categorized as some light blues with the saxophone going off, but maybe that's just what country did in the 70s like what rock did in the 80s

I like the busy ballad of Nothing Seems to Matter

I really liked "Too Long at the Fair," one that a few years ago I probably would have felt a little uncomfortable with